Big Star – Radio City …album review

I’ve reviewed the other two; now it’s time for Radio City. Some people rank this as their favorite Big Star album. I see why; it’s full of great songs, and Alex Chilton is at the top of his game here. For me, it’s hard to decide, but I always liked #1 Record, their debut, a touch better because of Chris Bell’s influence. Chris would leave the band after the debut album. But this one puts up great competition. Big Star is one of the reasons I started to blog in the first place. I thought if I turned one person on to this band, then I did my job.

Radio City was released in 1974 on Ardent Records. With Chris Bell gone, Big Star was basically Alex Chilton, Andy Hummel, and Jody Stephens. The change can be heard. #1 Record had a polished sound with Bell and Chilton balancing each other. Radio City is a little rougher and looser around the edges. That isn’t a criticism. It gives the album its own personality.

The album starts with O My Soul, and right away you know this isn’t simply #1 Record Part Two. It has more rhythm and a little more Memphis. Then you get songs like Way Out West, Daisy Glaze, You Get What You Deserve, and Back of a Car. There isn’t much wasted space on this album. Andy Hummel also deserves a lot of credit. He was more than just the bass player; ko contributed to several songs. Jody Stephens’ drumming is also a huge part of the sound.

And then there is September Gurls. If there were any justice in the music business, that song would have been all over the radio in 1974. Everything that makes Big Star great is packed into less than three minutes. The guitars ring, the melody sticks with you, and Chilton sounds effortless. It has since become one of their best-known songs, but at the time it went nowhere.

That was the story of Big Star. They received great reviews, but distribution problems kept their records out of stores. Radio City suffered the same fate as #1 Record. The people who heard it loved it. The problem was getting people the chance to hear it. Years later, bands such as R.E.M., The Replacements, Teenage Fanclub, and many others would make sure Big Star’s name didn’t disappear.

One of my favorites is Back of a Car. It has everything I like about this band. Great guitar, melody, and that slightly ragged quality that keeps Big Star from sounding too perfect. Chris Bell was gone by this point, but he had been involved in the early writing of the song before leaving the band. In a way, it provides a small bridge between the Big Star of #1 Record and the band heard on Radio City.

The album closes with the short and simple I’m in Love with a Girl. After everything that comes before it, Chilton ends the record with little more than an acoustic guitar and a melody. That’s another thing I love about Big Star. They didn’t need to make everything complicated. Give them a guitar and a good melody, and that was enough.

I can go back and forth between #1 Record and Radio City. If I had to choose, #1 Record still wins by a very small margin because I love what Chris Bell brought to the band. But ask me while September Gurls or Life Is White is playing, and I might change my answer.

Big Star never got the audience they deserved when these records were new. The good news is that the records never went away. People kept discovering them and passing them along to somebody else.

That’s really what happened to me. And if this post gets one more person to listen to Radio City, then Big Star is still gaining fans one person at a time.

September Girls

September girls do so much 
I was your Butch and you were touched 
I loved you, well, never mind 
I’ve been crying all the time 
December boy’s got it bad 
December boy’s got it bad 

September girls, I don’t know why 
How can I deny what’s inside 
Even though I’ll keep away 
They we’ll love all our days 
December boy’s got it bad 
December boy’s got it bad 

When I get to bed, late at night 
That’s the time she makes things right 
Ooh when she makes love to me 

September girls do so much 
I was your Butch and you were touched 
I loved you, well, never mind 
I’ve been crying all the time 
December boy’s got it bad 
December boy’s got it bad 
December boy’s got it bad, woo ooo


Discover more from PowerPop... An Eclectic Collection of Pop Culture

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Badfinger (Max)

Power Pop fan, Baseball, Beatles, Alternative music, old movies, and tv show fan. Also anything to do with pop culture in the 60s and 70s... I'm also a songwriter, bass and guitar player. Not the slightest bit interested in politics at all.

26 thoughts on “Big Star – Radio City …album review”

  1. First I have to say is what took you so long! Well at least the album story is complete but lots more to tell no doubt. I ran through the little snippets you get on the Spotify playlist and September Gurls is the only song I recognize. I can certainly see why you like these guys so much!

  2. Mission accomplished, Max, which now dates back several years! 🙂

    While I had known “September Gurls” since 1986 because of the great rendition by The Bangles (at the time not realizing this wasn’t their own song!), it’s 100 percent thanks to you I finally became aware of Big Star.

    Not only do I absolutely love their original of “September Gurls,” which is gorgeous power candy, but I also dig their other songs I’ve heard.

    And, yes, why that song didn’t become a hit back in May 1974 when Big Star released it as a single beats me. That said, I’m also somewhat surprised The Bangles didn’t include that gem on any of their five singles from their “Different Light” album.

    1. Yea it shouuld have been everywhere when this was released. It’s really a shame Christian… I put those two albums up with some Beatles albums…every song is good. I know that is saying a lot…but they had everything but the popularity.

  3. As you suggest, REM and The Bangles were among their many fans and tried to make them some money years later by either recording covers of their songs or playing benefit/tribute shows. I like the random few songs I’ve heard but never really got very into hearing their whole discography. Maybe someday I will.
    This album was one of the important ones in ‘Life is a Mix Tape’ by Rob Sheffield, a memoir. He essentially hooked up with his future wife when the album was put on in a bar and they were about the only two who seemed to know or like it

    1. I do put their first two albums up with some Beatles albums…and that is coming from me! They are that good to me. The melodies and harmonies are hard to beat. Yea I think the Replacements, REM, Jayhawks, and the Bangles did help them just by saying what an influence they were.

  4. Ah, Big Star; Has there ever been a sadder case of ‘wtf- why the frikkin hell didn’t this band be Dark Side Of The moon level? ‘Whats going Ahn?’ ‘Way Out West’ ‘September Gurls?’ There’s no justice, the f- fickle record buying public short-changed themselves.

      1. Yes, luck-wise they broke seven mirrors while driving under a ladder crossing the path of 13 black cats. Or something.

      2. LOL…yea…it’s not really funny but…it’s damn true! Obbverse I’ll be over before long. I got to visit a ship today that came through our town. An original WW2 ship…LST-325…so it’s been a long day…but I loved it…I’ll post about it this week…probably on Tuesday morning.

  5. I too flip between whether I like #1 or #2 better, but I must say that I am not much of a fan of Third.

    PS – I too love turning people on to Big Star and even got my son to use “I’m in Love With a Girl” as his wedding song. It did help that they played it on “House.”

  6. It’s my favourite, as you probably know, and its not close. I think O My Soul is almost the weakest cut, kind of generic compared to the rest, but still very good.

    1. With me it’s neck and neck…it does help that #1 contains one of my all time favorite songs period in The Ballad of El Goodo. I’ve come to like Life is White as well on this album a lot.

Leave a Reply