Tragically Hip – Bobcaygeon

This really shows you the power of blogs. Before I started to read them, I knew nothing about The Tragically Hip or other bands. Thanks to friends like Dave, Randy, Deke, CB, and others…I’ve been introduced to so many more acts.

I’ve been listening to more music by The Tragically Hip lately, and this one caught my attention. I love the acoustic guitar in this song and the way the music moves along. It has a relaxed, almost hypnotic feel, and Gord Downie’s vocals fit it perfectly. The song appeared on the Canadian band’s 1998 album Phantom Power. The Tragically Hip were enormously popular in Canada, but never achieved quite the same recognition in the United States. That’s a shame, because they made some wonderful music and deserved more attention than they got.

The song takes its name from Bobcaygeon, a small town in Ontario, Canada. Downie tells the story of a police officer working in Toronto who finds himself thinking about someone he loves in Bobcaygeon. He’s tired of the city and the trouble that comes with his job. The song also mentions a riot and contains references that have been connected to racism and antisemitism in Toronto’s history. Some listeners believe it refers to the Christie Pits riot of 1933, although the meaning isn’t completely settled. Underneath all of that is a man who would rather be somewhere peaceful with someone he loves.

What I enjoy most is the music itself. The acoustic guitar carries the song beautifully, and the arrangement builds without ever becoming overpowering. There’s a certain sadness in Downie’s voice, but there’s also a feeling of hope. I like songs that can create an atmosphere like this without needing a lot of production. I didn’t know what it was about when I first heard it, but the music was enough to make me want to hear it again. Now that I know a little more about the story, I appreciate it even more.

Bobcaygeon

I left your house this mornin’
About a quarter after nine
Could have been the Willie Nelson
Could have been the wine

When I left your house this mornin’
It was a little after nine
It was in Bobcaygeon, I saw the constellations
Reveal themselves one star at a time

Drove back to town this mornin’
With workin’ on my mind
I thought of maybe quittin’
I thought of leavin’ it behind

I went back to bed this mornin’
And as I’m pullin’ down the blind
Yeah, the sky was dull, and hypothetical
And fallin’ one cloud at a time

That night in Toronto
With its checkerboard floors
Riding on horseback
And keepin’ order restored

‘Til the men, they couldn’t hang
Stepped to the mic and sang
And their voices rang
With that Aryan twang

I got to your house this mornin’
Just a little after nine
In the middle of that riot
Couldn’t get you off my mind

So I’m at your house this mornin’
Just a little after nine
‘Cause it was in Bobcaygeon where I saw the constellations
Reveal themselves one star at a time


Discover more from PowerPop... An Eclectic Collection of Pop Culture

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Badfinger (Max)

Power Pop fan, Baseball, Beatles, Alternative music, old movies, and tv show fan. Also anything to do with pop culture in the 60s and 70s... I'm also a songwriter, bass and guitar player. Not the slightest bit interested in politics at all.

10 thoughts on “Tragically Hip – Bobcaygeon”

  1. I’ve enjoyed listening to them since I first saw them on your blog.
    They remind me of ‘The Go-Betweens’ in their homegrown, local, no nonsense sound and lyric.

  2. Same here, brother! I hadn’t heard of the group except for their name. Thanks to fellow bloggers from the musical treasure trove of Canada, I’m glad this has changed, though I still have lots of Tragically Hip listening to do. ‘Bobcaygeon’ sounds right up my alley!

  3. another truly Canadian sound right? like no one else….we seem to do that well, think of Neil Young, or Joni Mitchell, Bobcaygeon, Young’s Helpless, Mitchell’s River….and a lot like 54 40 or Blue Rodeo not being able to make an inroad into the USA mainstream…..the thing about the Hip and Gord Downie weren’t afraid to sing about Canada…..Bobcaygeon paints an amazing picture as much as the Canadian painters know as the Group of 7.

    1. Yes I love this…I like all of those bands you mentioned…and another…Kathleen Edwards…I love her song I Make The Dough, You Get the Glory.
      Also my favorite that all of you (I should have mentioned you!) have mentioned is The Blue Shadows…my absolute favorites…along with Sloan.

  4. Certainly were the ‘pride of Canada’ eh. They had a great run in the ’90s and this is one of the most enduringly popular of their songs maybe because it is very Canadian but it also showed their diversity. They started out almost Black Crowes-like garage rock but quickly expanded their sound, range and broad lyrical net, courtesy Gordon Downie. I’m glad you caught on to them!

    1. Yes I did…I was telling Warren…my favorite out of the Canadian bands…the two I go back to the most…are Sloan and The Blue Shadows…some great music that deserves to be heard.

Leave a Reply