Captain Beefheart, like Zappa, has always been known as odd. I love odd so that music fits me in a lot of ways. I’ve always liked the quirky artists who try something out of the ordinary and believe me…Captain Beefheart is that. This song has a hell of an intro groove to it. I also liked Happy Love Song.
Captain Beefheart was born Don Van Vliet and was a prodigious sculptor in his childhood. I first heard about him from a Beatles book…as I did with a lot of the artists I know. John and Paul were fans of his albums Trout Mask Replica and Safe As Milk. There are two stories about how he got his name – the one he gave to David Letterman was that he chose it because he had a “beef in his heart” about how humanity was ruining the environment.
This song and album are very accessible to a lot of people. It’s almost like he’s daring you to admit he can write “normal” without losing the weirdness. The song comes from the album Unconditionally Guaranteed in 1974, the Captain Beefheart album, where the edges got filed down. The band and some fans didn’t like the album because it was more conventional than some of his other albums. The man couldn’t win either way he went.
He is taking blues and R&B shapes and bending them until they look unfamiliar, but still feel like music you’ve heard and loved. He did bring in some other musicians on this album, like Mark Marcellino on keyboards, Andy DiMartino on guitar, and Del Simmons with the sax and flute. His Magic band played as well.
After this album, the Magic Band quit because of financial reasons and also because Beefheart ran a tight ship. Here is the full album Unconditionally Guaranteed on YouTube.
Upon the My-O-My
The decks were stacked
The wind blew low, the wind blew high
The stakes were low, the stakes were high
Upon the My-O-My
Hands low, hands high,
Ho-ho-ho, hi-hi-hi
Hands low, hands high
Upon the My-O-My
How was I to know she was so shy?
Upon the My-O-My
Across the light, across the night
You can hear the Captain’s cry
Hands low, hands high
Upon the My-O-My
Got to make her roll, got to make her fly
Upon the My-O-My
Now tell me, good Captain,
How does it feel
To be driven away from your own steering wheel
Upon the My-O-My . . .
…

If this dude was odd and wanted to market himself, he should have called one of his albums “Where’s The Beef?” By the sounds of your post dude was a little out there.
LikeLiked by 2 people
lol…he would have been before his time! Oh yes! Him and Zappa… they were out there…but sometimes we do need different.
LikeLiked by 1 person
With the other music I liked in those days, I was “supposed to” be a Captain Beefheart fan. I’ll have to admit I liked the concept of him more than the reality. HIs singing isn’t my favorite (though it beats the falsetto of the Bee Gees disco era).
LikeLiked by 2 people
I do like what I’ve heard…this album was probably more accessible than others.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree completely with your post. You took the words right out of my mouth. I was “supposed to” be a Captain Beefheart fan. YES!!! Liked the concept more than the reality! That’s me on Beefheart.
Thanks for making me feel eloquent this morning. 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
This song seems to be influenced by Cajun music, but I guess he covered many genres.
LikeLiked by 1 person
He did…he was all over the map.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh Jim…I should be in the Sunday Lyric tonight…sorry it has taken me so long.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sure, Max and you are welcome ever week. January 25, 2026 – Song that mentions cold and I am going with Cold Irons Bound by Bob Dylan.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ok cool! You were right…the Little Feat song would have went great…I’ll find one. You picked a perfect time for that one! We are looking at major snow and ice tonight.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well that’s different. I recognize the Captain from his album covers more than hearing his music, but the snippets I’ve heard have been too ‘out there’ for me. This one though isn’t too bad, though if I’d heard it back in the day it wouldn’t have come home with me. But it’s good to have a few weird, experimental artists doing their own thing
LikeLiked by 1 person
That other one….Happy Love Song…is pretty much straight up…some of his fans were upset this album wasn’t out there enough…what is that line? Ya can’t please everyone, so ya got to please yourself
LikeLiked by 1 person
gee that might make a good line in a song…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ll write that down!
LikeLike
A beef in my heart against the society
– Don Vliet, 1982
LikeLike