Billy Joel – The Ballad of Billy the Kid

I’m writing this for Song Lyric Sunday for Jim Adams. This week the theme is to find a song about the American West, or one that mentions cowboys, a sheriff, an outlaw, horses, cactus, or tumbleweeds. I’ve always liked songs that tell a story, and this song certainly does that. I participate in a blogging prompt every now and then, and this week’s theme was Westerns, so I had to join.

This song immediately came to mind. It appeared on Joel’s 1973 album Piano Man, and it sounds like something out of an old Western movie. It has everything from galloping rhythms to dramatic orchestration, and you can almost picture the gunfights and dusty streets as the song plays. Joel was only in his early twenties when he recorded it, but he was already showing what a great storyteller he could be.

The song follows the legendary outlaw Billy the Kid, although Joel wasn’t too concerned about historical accuracy. He has Billy robbing banks and traveling through places that don’t exactly match the real outlaw’s life. In fact, Joel has admitted that he took plenty of liberties with the story. The real Billy the Kid was associated mainly with New Mexico, not the adventures described in the song. But that’s part of the fun. Joel was writing a song inspired more by the legend of Billy the Kid than the actual man. The music even has a cinematic quality, with its strings and changes in tempo. It’s almost a little Western movie packed into five minutes.

What I like most about the song is the way Joel brings the story into the present at the end. After all the tales of the outlaw, he introduces another Billy, this time from Oyster Bay, Long Island. It’s a clever ending.

The last verse brings the story into the present with another Billy, this time from Oyster Bay, Long Island. Some people have interpreted that as Billy Joel writing about himself, but Joel explained that he was actually referring to Billy Nastri, a local bartender he knew. I like that little twist at the end. After all the stories about the famous outlaw, we end up with an ordinary guy from Long Island. I’ve always liked Billy Joel’s earlier albums, and this is one of those songs that shows why. He could take a simple idea and turn it into something much bigger. It might not be a very accurate history lesson, but it’s a great song. And sometimes that’s all I ask for.

The album peaked at #27 on the Billboard Album Charts, #26 in Canada, and #98 in the UK in 1973. The song was released as a single in 1974 but didn’t chart.

The Ballad of Billy The Kid

From a town known as Wheeling, West Virginia
Rode a boy with a six-gun in his hand
And his daring life of crime
Made him a legend in his time
East and west of the Rio Grande

Well, he started with a bank in Colorado
In the pocket of his vest, a Colt he hid
And his age and his size
Took the teller by surprise
And the word spread of Billy the Kid

Well, he never traveled heavy
Yes, he always rode alone
And he soon put many older guns to shame
And he never had a sweetheart
And he never had a home
But the cowboy and the rancher knew his name

Well, he robbed his way from Utah to Oklahoma
And the law just could not seem to track him down
And it served his legend well
For the folks, they loved to tell
‘Bout when Billy the Kid came to town

Well, one cold day, a posse captured Billy
And the judge said, “String him up for what he did!”
And the cowboys and their kin
Like the sea came pourin’ in
To watch the hanging of Billy the Kid

Well, he never traveled heavy
Yes, he always rode alone
And he soon put many older guns to shame
And he never had a sweetheart
But he finally found a home
Underneath the boot hill grave that bears his name

From a town known as Oyster Bay, Long Island
Rode a boy with a six-pack in his hand
And his daring life of crime
Made him a legend in his time
East and west of the Rio Grande

Billy Joel – Captain Jack

I’ve never been a huge Billy Joel fan, but I do like a lot of his music. I had the Songs In The Attic album, and this is one of the songs that stood out. This is early 1970s Billy, restless and writing about disillusionment, very different from Uptown Girl Billy. I would even say this might be one of the most important songs of his career because of what followed. 

Captain Jack is the drug dealer who breaks up the humdrum life of the narrator. Joel didn’t try to hide that in the lyrics at all. Some stations wouldn’t touch it, but others couldn’t stop spinning it. Joel later said the song wasn’t a glamorization, just an observation of what he’d seen in the Long Island neighborhoods where he grew up.

His debut album, Cold Spring Harbor, had been released with a massive technical flaw; the entire thing was mastered at the wrong speed, making Joel’s voice sound unnaturally high. Promotion was minimal, sales were bad, and Joel was locked into a contract that basically gave him pennies per record. He then did the only thing he could do…tour. 

The song had quite an effect on Joel. Philadelphia’s WMMR-FM invited Joel to perform a live concert in their tiny Sigma Sound Studios space,  just him, drummer Rhys Clark, and bassist Larry Russell. The station’s program director, Michael Tearson, and DJ Ed Sciaky were championing singer-songwriters, and Joel’s Cold Spring Harbor tracks had caught their ear despite the bad pressing.

Joel played an eight-song set, mixing early album cuts with unreleased songs. One of those was Captain Jack. The live performance of this song was rawer and darker than the album tracks he’d been promoting. Listeners lit up the station’s phones, demanding to know where they could buy the song.

Here’s the thing: they couldn’t. Captain Jack wasn’t on Cold Spring Harbor. It wasn’t on any record. WMMR started playing the tape of that live performance regularly, and soon it was one of the station’s most requested tracks,  sometimes more than the current hits by Elton John or the Stones.

The WMMR Captain Jack proved Joel had an audience and that he could connect on FM radio without a hit single. By 1973, Columbia had signed him, sent him to Los Angeles with producer Michael Stewart, and Piano Man was born. This was the closing song on the album that included Piano Man and The Ballad of Billy the Kid. 

Captain Jack

Saturday night and you’re still hangin’ aroundTired of living in your one horse townYou’d like to find a little hole in the groundFor a while, hmm

So you go to the village in your tie-dye jeansAnd you stare at the junkies and the closet queensIt’s like some pornographic magazineAnd you smile, hmm

Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandCaptain Jack will get you by tonightJust a little push, and you’ll be smilin’Oh, yeah

Your sister’s gone out, she’s on a dateAnd you just sit at home and masturbateYour phone is gonna ring soonBut you just can’t wait for that call, hmm

So you stand on the corner in your New English clothesAnd you look so polished from your hair down to your toesOh, but still your fingers gonna pick your nose after all, hmm

But Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandCaptain Jack will get you by tonightJust a little push, and you’ll be smilin’, ohOh, yeah-yeah

So you decide to take a holidayYou got your tape deck and your brand-new ChevroletAh, there ain’t no place to go anywayWhat for? Hmm

So you got everything, ah, but nothing’s coolThey just found your father in the swimming poolAnd you guess you won’t be going back to school anymore

But Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandOh, Captain Jack will get you by tonightJust a little push and you’ll be smilin’, oh yeah

So you play your albums, and you smoke your potAnd you meet your girlfriend in the parking lotOh, but still you’re aching for the things you haven’t gotWhat went wrong? Hmm

And if you can’t understand why your world is so deadWhy you’ve got to keep in style and feed your headWell, you’re 21 and still your mother makes your bedAnd that’s too long, whoa, yeah-yeah

But Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandWell, now Captain Jack will get you by tonightJust a little push and you’ll be smilin’

Oh, Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandWell, now Captain Jack will make you to high tonightJust a little push and you’ll be smilin’

Yeah, Captain Jack will get you high tonightAnd take you to your special islandCaptain Jack will get you by tonightWell, now Captain Jack will make you to high tonight

…